Books That Suck, Volume One

Comments

Far From The Madding Crowd. In fact, anything by Thomas "needless waste of paper, you amazon rainforest killing eejit" Hardy. It's really quite simple. Girl meets boy, girl meets other boy, girl meets other other boy. Chaps squabble over her like little children. Someone dies. Someone else dies. It's like dating by bloody attrition. Not good.

I have to say, A Tale of Two Cities has been taunting me from my bookshelf for nearly two years now. Everytime I pick it up I do what you do and don't get past sentence one. I had a friend who used to do that with War & Peace only his mysterious quitting point was page 18. Everytime.

Seriously though, how can you not enjoy Gatsby? After I found out you liked the third man I honestly thought "It's quite possible she has perfect taste. (much like me, naturally.)" But this, this makes me wonder. :P
I've never read Thomas Hardy but that description certainly doesn't want me to!

LOL. Maybe I'm the one who has perfect taste, and since you like Gatsby, you're the one who's lacking :p Actually, I need to reread it sometime. It might not be as boring as I remember, but I remember being highly disappointed in it.
Oh, please, never ever do read Thomas Hardy. I'd feel so guilty for not having done more to prevent it. I think I'd feel like one of those people who tries to talk people down off the cliff edge and fails, only Thomas Hardy is a fate worse than sharp rocks and sea. (Okay, okay, so I may have irrational hatred here.)

I can't believe you suggested my taste may be less than perfect, that is just so mean! ;)

I do wonder if perhaps it's to do with expectations and habitat. Nothing seems to ever live up to the hype, and reading something because you have to at school and because you happened to pick it up in a shop must make you approach them differently. (Unless it's Hardy. Ug.) I bought Gatsby on a whim not knowing much about it and read it in the sunshine, so maybe it's also about when and where you first read them.

Perhaps I write too long comments and waffle an awful lot, sorry!
That's absolutely true. If I hadn't had heard that The Great Gatsby was #2 on that list, I'm sure I would have liked it a lot more.

Psh, I like your comments, waffle away!
I was letdown by Gatsby as well. A lot of people I've spoken with about favorite books often list Gatsby as one... I probably grimace each time.
I have to say mind, the end was the worst thing ever. I think it had to end that way to be a good book, but I rather liked Gatsby couldn't they have killed some of the less sympathetic characters instead? No one would have missed Tom and Daisy, you know, had they been sucked up by a tornado or something.

Anyway, I'm going to leave you two to under value it while I go get my morning cuppa' in my Penguin Classics Gatsby mug :P

p.s ) - like your new profile pic.
I agree, Daisy was so boring.

Thanks!

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in